1984 by George Orwell

 1984/Nineteen Eighty Four

George Orwell

Summary

George Orwell’s 1984 is a dystopian novel set in a totalitarian society ruled by the Party, led by the omnipresent and omnipotent figurehead Big Brother. The story takes place in Airstrip One (formerly Great Britain), a province of the superstate Oceania, where the government exerts absolute control over every aspect of life—thought, language, history, and even reality itself.

The protagonist, Winston Smith, works at the Ministry of Truth, where his job is to alter historical records to fit the Party’s ever-changing version of the past. Despite outward conformity, Winston harbors rebellious thoughts against the regime and begins a secret love affair with Julia, a fellow worker who also despises the Party.

Together, they seek personal freedom and truth. They are lured into what they believe is a resistance movement led by the mysterious figure Emmanuel Goldstein, the supposed leader of a revolutionary group. However, their rebellion is short-lived. They are betrayed, arrested by the Thought Police, and tortured in the dreaded Ministry of Love.

Under brutal psychological and physical torture, Winston is forced to betray Julia and ultimately is brainwashed into loving Big Brother. The novel ends with Winston, once a rebel, now a broken man, accepting the Party’s lies and losing all sense of individuality and truth.

 Critical Analysis

Introduction

George Orwell’s 1984 stands as one of the most powerful and influential dystopian novels of the 20th century. Published in 1949, in the aftermath of World War II and during the rise of authoritarian regimes, the novel offers a chilling vision of a future dominated by oppressive political control, manipulation of truth, and the erasure of individual freedom. Set in the fictional superstate of Oceania, 1984 explores the mechanisms through which a totalitarian regime exerts control over not only public behavior but also private thought and memory. Orwell, with his lucid prose and profound political insight, constructs a nightmarish world in which reality itself is subject to revision and where the concept of truth is entirely subordinated to power. This critical analysis examines the novel through its themes, structure, style, tone, language, characters, and plot, shedding light on Orwell’s enduring warning against the dangers of unchecked political authority and the dehumanizing effects of ideological tyranny.

1. Themes:

a. Totalitarianism and Oppression:

The novel is a searing critique of totalitarian regimes. Orwell illustrates how absolute power leads to absolute control—not only of public behavior but also of private thought. The Party’s control extends into language, memory, and even perception.

b. Surveillance and Loss of Privacy:

The omnipresent figure of Big Brother symbolizes state surveillance. Citizens are constantly watched through telescreens, and privacy is nonexistent. This theme resonates strongly in the modern digital age.

c. Manipulation of Truth and History:

“Who controls the past controls the future; who controls the present controls the past.” Orwell shows how truth becomes a political construct. Winston’s job—altering historical records—embodies the state’s power to redefine reality.

d. Language and Thought (Newspeak):

The invention of Newspeak, a language designed to eliminate rebellious thoughts, is Orwell’s powerful exploration of linguistic determinism. Thought is restricted by limiting vocabulary—demonstrating that controlling language is equivalent to controlling thought.

e. Rebellion and Conformity:

Winston and Julia's rebellion represents the human desire for freedom, love, and truth. However, Orwell pessimistically shows how rebellion is crushed and replaced with enforced conformity through indoctrination and torture.

2. Structure and Form:

• The novel is structured into three parts, each marking a shift in Winston’s psychological and physical journey:
• Part One: Introduction to the dystopian world and Winston’s initial rebellion.
• Part Two: His love affair with Julia and false hope of resistance.
• Part Three: His arrest, torture, reprogramming, and ultimate submission.
• Orwell employs the form of a dystopian novel, merging political satire, allegory, and philosophical narrative. The use of appendices, like “The Principles of Newspeak,” adds depth and realism to the fictional world.

3. Style:

• Orwell’s style is clear, direct, and journalistic. He uses simple, declarative sentences that mimic the mechanized and emotionally sterile world he portrays.
• This austere prose complements the bleakness of the setting, creating an oppressive atmosphere.

4. Tone and Mood:

• Tone: The tone is grim, detached, and bleak. Orwell rarely allows emotional indulgence, reflecting the emotional numbness of a repressive state.
• Mood: The mood is claustrophobic, paranoid, and hopeless. The reader is made to feel the suffocating weight of constant surveillance and fear.

5. Diction and Language:

• Orwell’s diction is precise and unembellished. He deliberately avoids ornate language to emphasize clarity and contrast it with the manipulative language of the Party.
• Newspeak and Party slogans (“War is Peace,” “Freedom is Slavery,” “Ignorance is Strength”) showcase how language is weaponized for control.

6. Figurative Language:

While Orwell's prose is largely literal, he uses symbolism and metaphor effectively:

• Big Brother: A symbol of the omniscient, authoritarian state.
• Room 101: A metaphor for personal psychological terror—the space where one's deepest fear becomes the tool of control.
• The paperweight: Symbolizes the fragile, beautiful remnants of the past, ultimately shattered like Winston’s hopes.
• Doublethink: A central Orwellian concept—a metaphor for the mental gymnastics required to believe contradictory ideas, reflecting the psychological manipulation under dictatorship.

7. Characters:

a. Winston Smith:

An everyman anti-hero who begins as a quiet rebel. He seeks truth, memory, and love. His transformation from resistance to total submission shows the terrifying power of ideological control.

b. Julia:

More pragmatic than Winston, Julia rebels through personal freedom and physical pleasure rather than ideology. She represents the body's rebellion against the mind’s enslavement.

c. O'Brien:

A complex villain who lures Winston into rebellion only to break him. O'Brien represents the inner workings of the Party—intelligent, manipulative, and sadistic.

d. Big Brother:

Never physically present, Big Brother is a symbol of ultimate authority and the manufactured godhead of the state.

e. Emmanuel Goldstein:

Supposed leader of the resistance, whose reality is questionable. He functions as a scapegoat and object of hate, used by the Party to unify the population through fear.

8. Plot:

The plot unfolds in a dystopian society where individuality is suppressed:

• Winston secretly resents the Party and dreams of rebellion.
• He starts a forbidden relationship with Julia and believes in a resistance movement.
• They are betrayed, arrested, and tortured in the Ministry of Love.
• Winston is forced to betray Julia and undergoes psychological reconditioning.
• In the end, Winston becomes a loyal subject of Big Brother, having lost all resistance and even his sense of self.

The plot moves from incipient hope to total despair, reinforcing the central warning of the novel.

Conclusion

1984 is a chilling prophecy and a timeless political warning. Orwell creates a terrifyingly plausible dystopia, where even thought is not free and reality is what the state says it is. Through his stark style, penetrating themes, and powerful symbols, Orwell warns against the seductive power of authoritarianism and the loss of humanity through state control. The novel’s enduring relevance in an age of mass surveillance, media manipulation, and ideological extremism makes it a masterpiece of 20th-century literature and an essential text for understanding the perils of unchecked power.

 

Vendor of Sweets by R. K. Narayan

The Vendor of Sweets 

R. K. Narayan

The Vendor of Sweets (1967) is a novel set in the fictional South Indian town of Malgudi and follows the life of Jagan, a traditional, Gandhian sweet vendor. He is in his mid-fifties, deeply rooted in Indian values, and proud of his simple, pious lifestyle. He runs a successful sweetmeat shop and adheres to natural living, reading the Bhagavad Gita, and practicing vegetarianism.

The story primarily revolves around Jagan’s relationship with his only son, Mali, a young man influenced by Western culture. Mali rejects his father’s values and travels to America to study creative writing. He later returns with a foreign woman, Grace, whom he introduces as his wife, though the marriage is never legally confirmed.

Conflict arises when Mali expresses his desire to launch a modern story-writing machine business and asks Jagan for financial support. Jagan is conflicted—he wants to support his son but is disturbed by Mali’s arrogance, materialism, and disdain for tradition. Tensions deepen as Jagan realizes how wide the gap has grown between them.

Eventually, Jagan decides to quietly withdraw from the business and from Mali’s life. He entrusts his shop to his cousin and retreats into spiritual contemplation, symbolizing a return to inner peace and detachment.

Critical Appreciation

Introduction:

R. K. Narayan’s The Vendor of Sweets is a poignant and subtly satirical novel that explores the conflict between tradition and modernity through the relationship between a father and his son. Set in the fictional South Indian town of Malgudi, the novel reflects the nuances of postcolonial India where old values are questioned by a new generation influenced by Western ideologies. With gentle irony and a sympathetic eye, Narayan dissects the generational divide with remarkable psychological insight and cultural sensitivity.

Themes:

1. Tradition vs. Modernity:

The central theme is the tension between Indian traditionalism and Western modernity. Jagan embodies the conservative Gandhian ethos, while Mali represents the allure and recklessness of Western ideals and consumerism.

2. Generational Conflict:

The novel explores the emotional and ideological disconnect between Jagan and Mali, highlighting how changes in values and lifestyles alienate parents from their children.

3. Detachment and Renunciation:

Jagan’s journey from attachment to detachment echoes the Hindu spiritual ideal of renouncing worldly ties for inner peace, which is subtly modeled on the Bhagavad Gita and Gandhian values.

4. Identity and Alienation:

Mali's foreign education and cultural assimilation alienate him from his roots. His inability to belong fully to either world reflects the confusion of postcolonial identity.

5. Moral Ambiguity and Human Fallibility:

Narayan avoids black-and-white moral judgments. Both Jagan and Mali are flawed—Jagan is self-righteous and evasive, while Mali is arrogant and irresponsible. The novel examines their humanity with subtle irony.

Structure and Form:

• The novel follows a linear narrative structure with a third-person omniscient narrator. The events unfold chronologically and focus on a limited number of characters.
• The form is that of a realistic novel, firmly rooted in domestic realism, where everyday occurrences serve as vessels for larger philosophical concerns.

Plot:

The plot is deceptively simple:

• Jagan, a widowed sweet vendor, lives a modest life rooted in tradition.
• His son Mali rejects his father’s lifestyle and goes to America to study creative writing.
• Mali returns with a foreign woman, Grace, and a business proposal for a story-writing machine.
• Jagan becomes increasingly disillusioned with his son’s materialism and detachment.
• When Mali is arrested for drunk driving, Jagan does not intervene. Instead, he quietly withdraws from both his business and familial responsibilities, choosing a life of contemplation and detachment.

The plot is not action-driven but psychologically and emotionally layered, offering insights into the characters' inner lives.

Characters:

• Jagan: A deeply traditional and moralistic man, Jagan represents the ideal of Gandhian simplicity. However, his passive approach to parenting and self-deception about his own shortcomings make him a complex, believable character.
• Mali: Jagan’s son, impulsive and Westernized, embodies the cultural confusion of postcolonial Indian youth. He seeks success and independence but lacks emotional maturity and cultural rootedness.
• Grace: A quiet but sympathetic character who tries to bridge the cultural divide. Her politeness contrasts with Mali’s brashness, making her a symbol of potential harmony between East and West.
• The Cousin: Jagan’s unnamed cousin plays the role of a go-between and comic relief, often manipulating Jagan gently, yet offering practical wisdom.

Diction and Style:

• Narayan’s diction is simple, clear, and conversational, accessible to a wide audience. He avoids ornate or overly literary language, choosing understatement and subtlety over dramatics.
• His style is marked by:
• Dry humor and gentle irony
• Use of dialogue to reveal character psychology
• A focus on ordinary life, showing the profundity in the mundane
• A calm, observant tone, akin to a philosophical tale rather than a dramatic narrative

Figurative Language:

• Narayan uses metaphors and symbolism sparingly but meaningfully:
• Sweets symbolize comfort, tradition, and material success rooted in simplicity.
• The story-writing machine is a metaphor for the mechanization and commercialization of art and creativity.
• Jagan’s retreat into solitude reflects the Indian ideal of vanaprastha (spiritual withdrawal in old age).
• Irony is a key device, especially in how characters fail to see their own contradictions.

Conclusion:

The Vendor of Sweets is a rich, introspective novel that combines cultural critique, psychological depth, and gentle humor. Through the life of a simple sweet vendor and his alienated son, R. K. Narayan masterfully examines the transition of Indian society, the struggles of parenthood, and the search for peace amidst turmoil. The novel is both culturally specific and universally resonant, standing as a testament to Narayan’s skill as a storyteller of quiet, meaningful revolutions in ordinary lives.

 

On the Move by Thom Gunn

 On the Move

By Thom Gunn

The blue jay scuffling in the bushes follows

Some hidden purpose, and the gust of birds

That spurts across the field, the wheeling swallows,

Has nested in the trees and undergrowth.

Seeking their instinct, or their poise, or both,

One moves with an uncertain violence

Under the dust thrown by a baffled sense

Or the dull thunder of approximate words.

On motorcycles, up the road, they come:

Small, black, as flies hanging in heat, the Boys,

Until the distance throws them forth, their hum

Bulges to thunder held by calf and thigh.

In goggles, donned impersonality,

In gleaming jackets trophied with the dust,

They strap in doubt – by hiding it, robust –

And almost hear a meaning in their noise.

Exact conclusion of their hardiness

Has no shape yet, but from known whereabouts

They ride, direction where the tyres press.

They scare a flight of birds across the field:

Much that is natural, to the will must yield.

Men manufacture both machine and soul,

And use what they imperfectly control

To dare a future from the taken routes.

It is a part solution, after all.

One is not necessarily discord

On earth; or damned because, half animal,

One lacks direct instinct, because one wakes

Afloat on movement that divides and breaks.

One joins the movement in a valueless world,

Choosing it, till, both hurler and the hurled,

One moves as well, always toward, toward.

A minute holds them, who have come to go:

The self-defined, astride the created will

They burst away; the towns they travel through

Are home for neither bird nor holiness,

For birds and saints complete their purposes.

At worst, one is in motion; and at best,

Reaching no absolute, in which to rest,

One is always nearer by not keeping still.

Glossary

Blue jay
A brightly colored bird known for its intelligence and loud calls

Scuffling
Moving with quick, confused, or noisy motions—suggests the bird is searching or struggling in the bushes.

Hidden purpose
An unseen or mysterious motive; implies that even nature’s actions may have meaning beyond human understanding.

Gust of birds
A sudden, forceful movement of a group of birds; likened to a gust of wind—emphasizing energy and unpredictability.

Spurts
Bursts or sudden rushes; refers to the way the birds fly across the field.

Wheeling swallows
Swallows flying in circular or graceful patterns—symbolizing freedom, grace, or instinctive motion.

Nestled in the trees and undergrowth
Birds settling or living in trees and low vegetation—implying home, instinct, or shelter in nature.

Poise
Balance or composure; the birds (or metaphorically people) may be seeking harmony or steadiness.

Dust thrown by a baffled sense
Confusion clouding perception; the metaphor suggests that the senses are overwhelmed or misdirected.

Dull thunder of approximate words
Refers to the inability of language to fully express meaning—words are imprecise, and communication becomes heavy and unclear.

 Up the road

Suggests the approach of the riders from a distance, emphasizing anticipation and movement.

Small, black, as flies hanging in heat
A simile comparing the approaching boys on motorcycles to black flies in hot weather—conveys a sense of menace, insignificance, or irritation.

Distance throws them forth
As the boys get closer, they emerge from the blur of distance into sharp focus—implies sudden presence or impact.

Their hum bulges to thunder
The soft sound of approaching engines grows louder and more intense, turning into a thunderous roar—evoking power and tension.

Held by calf and thigh
Describes how the riders grip the motorcycles with their legs—emphasizes control, masculinity, and physicality.

Donned impersonality

Wearing a look of emotional detachment—suggests a mask-like appearance, suppressing individual personality.

Gleaming jackets trophied with the dust
Shiny jackets covered in dust from the road—dust acts like a badge of pride or experience.

Strap in doubt – by hiding it, robust
Though they may feel uncertain or insecure, they hide it behind a display of strength and confidence.

Almost hear a meaning in their noise
Suggests a yearning for purpose or identity—trying to find meaning in the loudness or chaos they create.

 Exact conclusion of their hardiness

The final outcome or purpose of their toughness or daring behavior is not yet clear—suggests uncertainty about their future or identity.

Has no shape yet
There is no defined form or destiny—their journey or end remains unknown or unformed.

Hurler and the hurled: the dual role of controlling and being controlled by life’s momentum.

Toward, toward: Relentless forward motion. The destination is unspecified, implying that purpose lies in the act of moving itself, not necessarily in the goal.

A minute holds them, who have come to go
A brief pause before departure—those who are constantly moving or seeking don’t linger long.

Astride 
Riding or being in control of a will or drive that they themselves have formed—symbolizes conscious, self-chosen movement or motivation.

Critical Appreciation of "On the Move" by Thom Gunn

Thom Gunn’s “On the Move” is a reflective and philosophical poem that explores the tension between motion and stillness, purpose and purposelessness, freedom and constraint, especially within the context of post-war masculinity and existential uncertainty. The poem uses the image of leather-clad bikers speeding down roads to symbolically examine the human condition in a modern, dislocated world.

Themes

1.      Restlessness and Search for Purpose:                                                                                
The poem deals with existential restlessness. The bikers are constantly on the move, searching for meaning in a world where traditional values have faded. Movement itself becomes a metaphor for the search for identity and direction.

2.      Masculine Identity and Performance:                                                                                           
Gunn presents the bikers as “the Boys,” whose tough appearance hides inner doubt. Their leather jackets, goggles, and powerful machines become symbols of constructed masculinity and emotional suppression.

3.      Freedom vs. Control:                                                                                                                       
There’s a tension between the freedom of riding and the limits of human control. Though the bikers seem autonomous, they ride paths already laid down. Gunn subtly critiques the illusion of total freedom.

4.      Existentialism and Modern Dislocation:                                                                            
The poem engages with existential ideas—there is no fixed “absolute” or resting point. Humans are both “hurler and hurled,” acting and being acted upon in a world without inherent value.

5.      Nature vs. Mechanism:                                                                                                        
Birds, trees, and instinct represent the organic world, while motorcycles and dust symbolize human artifice. The poem questions whether humans can find the same unity with purpose that nature seems to possess.

Style and Form

The poem is written in regular iambic pentameter with a loose but consistent rhyme scheme, giving it a steady, deliberate rhythm that mirrors the motion of the motorcycles. Gunn uses formal structure to bring control and clarity to his philosophical reflections, a typical feature of his early poetry.

Despite the structured form, the diction is modern and accessible, blending formal poetic elements with contemporary imagery. This juxtaposition enhances the poem’s exploration of modernity’s challenges.

Tone

The tone is contemplative, philosophical, and at times melancholic. While Gunn admires the energy and defiance of the bikers, he also recognizes the futility in their ceaseless movement. There is a detached sympathy in the tone—a recognition of shared human striving without romanticizing it.

Structure

The poem is structured in five stanzas, each developing a different facet of the central theme. The first stanzas set the scene with vivid imagery of birds and bikers, contrasting natural instinct with human doubt. Midway, Gunn delves into philosophical inquiry, reflecting on human will, artifice, and the search for meaning. The final stanzas offer a resolution—not a conclusion, but an acceptance: the act of moving forward is, in itself, a form of purpose.

Mood

The mood fluctuates between restless energy and reflective resignation. The initial imagery is dynamic and full of movement, but as the poem progresses, a sense of philosophical weight and emotional weariness settles in. The closing lines offer a kind of stoic hope—“one is always nearer by not keeping still”—suggesting movement as the only way to approach understanding, even if the destination is unclear.

Literary Devices

1.      Simile and Metaphor:

o    "Small, black, as flies" evokes insignificance and menace.

o    “Hurler and the hurled” captures the duality of agency and passivity.

2.      Enjambment:

o    Lines often run into one another, reflecting the unbroken, continuous motion of the riders and the stream of thought.

3.      Symbolism:

o    Motorcycles symbolize modern freedom and alienation.

o    Birds represent instinct, natural purpose, and grace.

4.      Irony:

o    The bikers seem powerful and free, but their journey is shaped by routes already “taken,” and their confidence hides doubt.

Conclusion

“On the Move” is a richly layered poem that explores the existential dilemma of modern man through powerful imagery, disciplined form, and philosophical insight. Gunn’s use of the biker as a symbol of 20th-century dislocation allows him to interrogate the human need for direction in a world devoid of fixed values. Through its balanced tone, carefully structured form, and thoughtful engagement with modern identity, the poem remains a compelling meditation on motion as both metaphor and condition of life. 

 

Detailed Explanation

Stanza 1: 

    The blue jay scuffling in the bushes follows

Some hidden purpose, and the gust of birds

That spurts across the field, the wheeling swallows,

Has nested in the trees and undergrowth.

Seeking their instinct, or their poise, or both,

One moves with an uncertain violence

Under the dust thrown by a baffled sense

Or the dull thunder of approximate words.

    This stanza explores the contrast between the natural world’s instinctive motion and the human struggle for meaning and clarity. The blue jay scuffling in the bushes and the swallows wheeling through the air seem to follow some hidden yet purposeful instinct. Their movements, though rapid and unpredictable, are guided by a natural order—they nest in trees and undergrowth, grounded in their environment. This represents a kind of harmony and balance inherent in the animal world. In contrast, the human figure in the stanza moves with “an uncertain violence,” suggesting emotional turmoil and a lack of direction. Unlike the birds, people often lack clear instinct or poise, and instead, they struggle to navigate a world filled with confusion. This confusion is symbolized by the “dust thrown by a baffled sense,” indicating clouded perception, and by the “dull thunder of approximate words,” which reveals the inadequacy of language to fully express complex inner experiences. The stanza highlights themes such as the divide between instinct and reason, the insufficiency of language, and human alienation from the natural flow of life. Ultimately, it portrays the human condition as one of restless searching, in contrast to the seamless, instinctive existence of animals.

Stanza 2: 

    On motorcycles, up the road, they come:

Small, black, as flies hanging in heat, the Boys,

Until the distance throws them forth, their hum

Bulges to thunder held by calf and thigh.

In goggles, donned impersonality,

In gleaming jackets trophied with the dust,

They strap in doubt – by hiding it, robust –

And almost hear a meaning in their noise. 

    This stanza vividly captures the arrival of a group of young men on motorcycles, symbolizing a restless, rebellious spirit. They are first seen from a distance, appearing small and black “as flies hanging in heat”—a simile that suggests their insignificance, anonymity, and perhaps a slight menace. As they come closer, the soft hum of their engines swells into a thunderous roar, emphasizing their powerful presence and the physical control they assert, “held by calf and thigh.” Their goggles and dust-covered jackets create a uniform appearance, projecting a hardened, impersonal identity. The phrase “donned impersonality” suggests that they have adopted a deliberate detachment, a way to mask vulnerability. Their dust-covered jackets become trophies of experience, signs of their journey and struggle. The line “they strap in doubt – by hiding it, robust –” reveals that beneath their tough exterior lies uncertainty or insecurity, which they conceal through their aggressive posturing. Finally, the stanza ends on a poignant note: “they almost hear a meaning in their noise,” implying a desperate search for purpose or identity through the very chaos and sound they create. The stanza explores themes of youth, masculinity, performance, and the search for meaning in a seemingly indifferent world.

Stanza 3: 

Exact conclusion of their hardiness

Has no shape yet, but from known whereabouts

They ride, direction where the tyres press.

They scare a flight of birds across the field:

Much that is natural, to the will must yield.

Men manufacture both machine and soul,

And use what they imperfectly control

To dare a future from the taken routes.

    This stanza reflects on the uncertain yet determined journey of individuals who move forward despite not knowing exactly where they are headed. Their "hardiness", or resilience, lacks a clear "conclusion"—there is no fixed outcome or final destination in sight. Yet, from "known whereabouts", they continue riding, guided only by the direction their "tyres press", suggesting instinctive or habitual movement rather than deliberate planning. Their passage startles a flight of birds, symbolizing the disruption of natural peace by human activity. The line "Much that is natural, to the will must yield" points to the dominance of human will over nature, highlighting how human ambition often overrides organic, instinctive patterns. The stanza deepens this idea by stating that "Men manufacture both machine and soul", suggesting that not only technology but even human identity is constructed. Yet, both are imperfectly controlled, indicating the limits of human mastery. In spite of this, people still "dare a future", courageously attempting to shape what lies ahead by following paths already begun—"taken routes". The stanza underscores themes of uncertainty, human agency, and the complex relationship between progress, control, and the natural world.

• Stanza 4: 

  It is a part solution, after all.
  

  One is not necessarily discord
  

  On earth; or damned because, half animal,
  

  One lacks direct instinct, because one wakes
  

  Afloat on movement that divides and breaks.
  

  One joins the movement in a valueless world,
  

  Choosing it, till, both hurler and the hurled,
  

  One moves as well, always toward, toward.

    The stanza acknowledges the existential uncertainty and fragmented experience of being human but offers a kind of resolution or coping strategy. It suggests that accepting life’s “movement that divides and breaks” is itself “a part solution.” Despite lacking the clarity of pure instinct—being “half animal”—humans are not necessarily doomed or in conflict (“discord”) with the world. Instead, one can find peace in embracing this complexity. Rather than resisting the chaos of existence or the lack of inherent meaning (“a valueless world”), one can choose to join the flow of life. In doing so, even as one is both the “hurler and the hurled”—both the one acting and being acted upon—there is movement forward. The solution lies in acceptance and engagement: to live is to move, to participate actively in the journey without expecting final answers. The repetition of “toward, toward” emphasizes that progress or meaning may not lie in a destination, but in the act of ongoing movement itself. Thus, the poem offers a way of living authentically in a fragmented world—by choosing motion, embracing ambiguity, and finding meaning in the striving.

Stanza 5: 

A minute holds them, who have come to go:

The self-defined, astride the created will

They burst away; the towns they travel through

Are home for neither bird nor holiness,

For birds and saints complete their purposes.

At worst, one is in motion; and at best,

Reaching no absolute, in which to rest,

One is always nearer by not keeping still.    

    This stanza reflects on the transient nature of those who are perpetually on the move, defining themselves through their own choices rather than fixed circumstances. "A minute holds them, who have come to go" implies that their presence is brief—a fleeting moment before they move on. These individuals, described as “the self-defined,” consciously harness a force—a created will—that propels them forward. They burst away into the world, leaving behind towns that offer no lasting refuge or identity, being unsuitable even for birds or saints who fulfill their complete, specific purposes. In contrast, the wanderers remain in a constant state of motion; even if their journey seems aimless at times (“at worst, one is in motion”), this very movement enables them to edge closer to a potential, elusive destination. Although they never reach an absolute state of rest or finality, their persistent pursuit ensures that they are always nearer to some form of fulfillment simply by refusing to stagnate.